StandardVerified Q1 2026

Source: Carrier website and product data

Selective Insurance: Auto Repair Shops Insurance Appetite

Selective Insurance writes auto repair shops at standard terms for clean accounts. Garage keepers is the essential coverage — protects against claims for damage to customer vehicles on your lot or in your shop

Available Lines

Line of Business
General Liability
Commercial Property
Workers' Compensation
Commercial Auto

Premium Range

$4,600-$26,400

Typical annual premium

Target States

25 states (Northeast, Mid-Atlantic, Southeast, Midwest)

Key Features

Limitations

Compare Other Carriers for Auto Repair Shops

Progressive CommercialStandard

$4,000-$22,000

TravelersPreferred

$4,600-$26,400

CNAStandard

$4,600-$26,400

HiscoxLimited

$6,000-$26,400

NEXT InsurancePreferred

$4,000-$22,000

The HartfordPreferred

$4,600-$26,400

EMPLOYERSPreferred

$1,600-$6,600

AcuityPreferred

$4,000-$22,000

Erie InsurancePreferred

$4,000-$22,000

biBERKPreferred

$4,000-$22,000

AmTrust FinancialPreferred

$4,000-$22,000

BTISStandard

$4,000-$22,000

Pie InsurancePreferred

$1,600-$6,600

NationwidePreferred

$4,600-$26,400

Liberty MutualStandard

$4,600-$26,400

ChubbStandard

$5,600-$33,000

Cincinnati FinancialStandard

$4,600-$26,400

The HanoverStandard

$4,600-$26,400

Auto-Owners InsurancePreferred

$4,000-$22,000

GUARD InsurancePreferred

$4,000-$22,000

MarkelStandard

$4,600-$26,400

Coterie InsurancePreferred

$4,000-$22,000

Kinsale CapitalStandard

$4,600-$26,400

InsureonPreferred

$4,000-$22,000

W.R. BerkleyStandard

Contact carrier for quote

FalveyLimited

Contact carrier for quote

West BendPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

AmeriTrustStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Farmers Mutual of SalemStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Arlington/RoeStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Southern OwnersPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Penn National InsurancePreferred

Contact carrier for quote

CitadelStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Central Insurance CompaniesPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Combined GroupPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

NICO (National Indemnity)Preferred

Contact carrier for quote

CBIZStandard

Contact carrier for quote

DUALLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Austin MutualStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Franklin MutualStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Capital InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

LOUDOUN MUTUALPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

VentureStandard

Contact carrier for quote

VouchStandard

Contact carrier for quote

EMC InsurancePreferred

Contact carrier for quote

ParagonStandard

Contact carrier for quote

RT SpecialtyStandard

Contact carrier for quote

AMERICAN UNDERWRITERSStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Ascot GroupLimited

Contact carrier for quote

IAT InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

DonegalStandard

Contact carrier for quote

TangramStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Grange InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

GlatfelterStandard

Contact carrier for quote

James RiverLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Hartford Accident and IndemnityPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Core Specialty InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Mountain States InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

NIPStandard

Contact carrier for quote

MSAStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Ryan SpecialtyStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Safety NationalStandard

Contact carrier for quote

General StarLimited

Contact carrier for quote

RLIStandard

Contact carrier for quote

HuckleberryStandard

Contact carrier for quote

ISCStandard

Contact carrier for quote

AcrisureStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Evanston / Markel SpecialtyStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Virginia Farm BureauStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Harco NationalLimited

Contact carrier for quote

HarleysvilleLimited

Contact carrier for quote

SPGStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Arbella InsurancePreferred

Contact carrier for quote

GallagherStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Global IndemnityPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Palomar E&SLimited

Contact carrier for quote

VictorStandard

Contact carrier for quote

AmTrust FinancialPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Argo GroupPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Norcal MutualPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

PPIBLimited

Contact carrier for quote

VeracityStandard

Contact carrier for quote

AGCSStandard

Contact carrier for quote

AllstateStandard

Contact carrier for quote

American Family InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Pacific Indemnity REStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Wesco InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

AlliantStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Charter Oak FireStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Meadowbrook InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

NY Marine (Fairfax subsidiary)Standard

Contact carrier for quote

OK Farm BureauStandard

Contact carrier for quote

State FarmStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Arch InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

SC Farm Bureau MutualStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Starr CompaniesLimited

Contact carrier for quote

AmbridgeStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Hanover ManufacturingStandard

Contact carrier for quote

IMTLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Oklahoma Farm Bureau InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

PPPStandard

Contact carrier for quote

The HanoverStandard

Contact carrier for quote

ABA InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Allied World InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Burns & WilcoxLimited

Contact carrier for quote

FCCIStandard

Contact carrier for quote

MiniCoStandard

Contact carrier for quote

SecuraStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Utica NationalPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

AccretiveStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Cumberland MutualStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Missouri Farm Bureau InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Old RepublicStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Pennsylvania Farm Bureau InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

RPSLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Rural MutualPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

StarwindStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Steadfast InsuranceLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Vanliner InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Amica MutualLimited

Contact carrier for quote

ArrowheadStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Catlin InsuranceLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Frankenmuth MutualStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Germania InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Intact/OneBeaconLimited

Contact carrier for quote

SentryPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Bass UnderwritersLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Charity FirstStandard

Contact carrier for quote

CovenantPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Employers Mutual CasualtyStandard

Contact carrier for quote

EriePreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Michigan Farm Bureau InsurancePreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Midwest Family MutualPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Philadelphia InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

WestfieldStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Everest InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Navigators SpecialtyLimited

Contact carrier for quote

QBE North AmericaStandard

Contact carrier for quote

SocietyPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

State AutoStandard

Contact carrier for quote

ThimbleStandard

Contact carrier for quote

DistinguishedStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Grinnell MutualPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Sompo InternationalStandard

Contact carrier for quote

BW CannabisLimited

Contact carrier for quote

CSAA InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

EmbrokerStandard

Contact carrier for quote

The Doctors CompanyStandard

Contact carrier for quote

USA InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

USLILimited

Contact carrier for quote

American CompensationStandard

Contact carrier for quote

American SpecialtyStandard

Contact carrier for quote

AonStandard

Contact carrier for quote

BIBStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Coastal AmericanPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Columbia InsurancePreferred

Contact carrier for quote

FederatedPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Interstate Fire & CasualtyLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Munich Re AmericaStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Patriot Insurance MEStandard

Contact carrier for quote

PekinPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

SafeCo by Liberty MutualStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Swiss Re Corp SolutionsLimited

Contact carrier for quote

ZurichStandard

Contact carrier for quote

AegisStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Ascendant CommercialStandard

Contact carrier for quote

AssurantStandard

Contact carrier for quote

CincinnatiPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

FarmersPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Guard (Berkshire Hathaway)Preferred

Contact carrier for quote

Motorists MutualPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

NautilusLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Ohio Farm Bureau InsuranceLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Palmetto SuretyLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Scottsdale InsuranceLimited

Contact carrier for quote

AF GroupPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Applied UnderwritersStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance (BHSI)Limited

Contact carrier for quote

Colorado Farm Bureau InsuranceStandard

Contact carrier for quote

HCC InsuranceLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Home-Owners InsurancePreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Navigators (Hartford subsidiary)Standard

Contact carrier for quote

Rain and Hail AgricultureStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Southern Farm Bureau CasualtyStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Tokio Marine AmericaStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Western NationalStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Columbia MutualPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

General Security IndemnityLimited

Contact carrier for quote

JencapPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Nodak Mutual / NI HoldingsLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Ohio MutualStandard

Contact carrier for quote

B&BStandard

Contact carrier for quote

COUNTRY FinancialPreferred

Contact carrier for quote

Indian Harbor InsuranceLimited

Contact carrier for quote

Main Street America Group (MSA)Standard

Contact carrier for quote

Ram MutualStandard

Contact carrier for quote

ACIGStandard

Contact carrier for quote

Back to Selective Insurance Profile

Stop wasting hours on quoting.
Start closing more business.

Book a free 15-min call · Your carriers running on day one

Book Free Setup Call ↗

No contracts. Setup takes 15 minutes.