PreferredVerified Q1 2026
Source: Carrier website and product data
Acuity: Auto Repair Shops Insurance Appetite
Acuity explicitly targets auto repair shops as a focus segment. Garage keepers is the essential coverage – protects against claims for damage to customer vehicles on your lot or in your shop
Available Lines
| Line of Business |
|---|
| General Liability |
| Commercial Property |
| Workers' Compensation |
| Commercial Auto |
Premium Range
$4,000-$22,000
Typical annual premium
Target States
29 states (Midwest and select Eastern states)
Key Features
- Workers' Compensation program – Coverage for employee injuries on the job, including access to the Acuity Nurse for auto repair shops class codes
- Acuity offers on-hook towing coverage for shops that offer tow service
- Acuity offers equipment breakdown covering lifts, compressors, and diagnostic equipment
- Online quoting available – agents can get auto repair shops quotes without calling underwriting
Limitations
- Standard BOP does NOT cover auto repair operations – requires garage-specific policy form
- Body shops with paint spray booths face additional fire underwriting and may require separate placement
- Performance modification and custom fabrication work is excluded by most standard markets
Compare Other Carriers for Auto Repair Shops
Progressive CommercialStandard
$4,000-$22,000
TravelersPreferred
$4,600-$26,400
CNAStandard
$4,600-$26,400
HiscoxLimited
$6,000-$26,400
NEXT InsurancePreferred
$4,000-$22,000
The HartfordPreferred
$4,600-$26,400
EMPLOYERSPreferred
$1,600-$6,600
Erie InsurancePreferred
$4,000-$22,000
biBERKPreferred
$4,000-$22,000
AmTrust FinancialPreferred
$4,000-$22,000
BTISStandard
$4,000-$22,000
Pie InsurancePreferred
$1,600-$6,600
NationwidePreferred
$4,600-$26,400
Liberty MutualStandard
$4,600-$26,400
ChubbStandard
$5,600-$33,000
Cincinnati FinancialStandard
$4,600-$26,400
The HanoverStandard
$4,600-$26,400
Auto-Owners InsurancePreferred
$4,000-$22,000
GUARD InsurancePreferred
$4,000-$22,000
MarkelStandard
$4,600-$26,400
Coterie InsurancePreferred
$4,000-$22,000
Selective InsuranceStandard
$4,600-$26,400
Kinsale CapitalStandard
$4,600-$26,400
InsureonPreferred
$4,000-$22,000