Source: Carrier website and product data
Where this rating comes from: QuoteSweep estimate from industry knowledge
No carrier page sits behind this rating. It is a QuoteSweep estimate, so treat it as a starting point and confirm with your underwriter. Last checked Q1 2026. See what carrier appetite means and how observed appetite differs from published appetite.
Pie Insurance: Auto Repair Shops Insurance Appetite
Pie Insurance has strong appetite for auto repair shops accounts. Fully digital quoting and binding process – Pie Insurance's platform is designed for fast turnaround on small auto repair shops accounts. Garage keepers is the essential coverage – protects against claims for damage to customer vehicles on your lot or in your shop
Available Lines
| Line of Business |
|---|
| General Liability |
| Commercial Property |
| Workers' Compensation |
Premium Range
$1,600-$6,600
Typical annual premium
Target States
37 states + DC
Key Features
- Workers' Compensation Insurance program – Helps businesses care for an injured employee by supplementing medical costs and for auto repair shops class codes
- Pie Insurance offers on-hook towing coverage for shops that offer tow service
- Pie Insurance offers equipment breakdown covering lifts, compressors, and diagnostic equipment
- Online quoting available – agents can get auto repair shops quotes without calling underwriting
Limitations
- No commercial auto available – must be placed separately for auto repair shops accounts with vehicles
- Standard BOP does NOT cover auto repair operations – requires garage-specific policy form
- Body shops with paint spray booths face additional fire underwriting and may require separate placement
How Pie Insurance compares for auto repair shops
QuoteSweep tracks 25 carriers for auto repair shops: 14 rated preferred, 10 standard, 1 limited and 0 that decline the class. Pie Insurance is rated preferred. These are QuoteSweep ratings, and not every one rests on a carrier's own guidelines.
Closest alternatives
- Acuity · Preferred · $4,000-$22,000
- AmTrust Financial · Preferred · $4,000-$22,000
- Auto-Owners Insurance · Preferred · $4,000-$22,000
Read the full Pie Insurance agent's guide for products, ratings and appointment notes across all classes.
Compare Other Carriers for Auto Repair Shops
$4,000-$22,000
$4,000-$22,000
$4,000-$22,000
$4,000-$22,000
$4,000-$22,000
$1,600-$6,600
$4,000-$22,000
$4,000-$22,000
$4,000-$22,000
$4,600-$26,400
$4,000-$22,000
$4,600-$26,400
$4,600-$26,400
$4,000-$22,000
$5,600-$33,000
$4,600-$26,400
$4,600-$26,400
$4,600-$26,400
$4,600-$26,400
$4,600-$26,400
$4,000-$22,000
$4,600-$26,400
$4,600-$26,400
$6,000-$26,400