Source: Auto-Owners Insurance – Retail Insurance
Where this rating comes from: Carrier guidelines
This rating rests on what the carrier publishes. Confirm eligibility with your underwriter before you quote. Last checked Q1 2026. See what carrier appetite means and how observed appetite differs from published appetite.
Auto-Owners Insurance: Retail Stores Insurance Appetite
Auto-Owners is one of the most competitive retail markets in the Midwest. Their pricing for Main Street retail is consistently among the lowest, and their claims handling is excellent. The exclusive agency model ensures strong local service. A go-to choice for independent agents placing small retail risks in their territory.
Available Lines
| Line of Business |
|---|
| General Liability |
| Business Owners Policy (BOP) |
| Workers' Compensation |
| Commercial Property |
| Commercial Auto |
| Umbrella/Excess |
Premium Range
$1,000-$7,500
Typical annual premium
Target States
26 states (Midwest and Southeast)
Key Features
- Broad BOP with equipment breakdown and business income coverage
- Very competitive property rates for Midwest Main Street retail
- Workers' comp with retail safety programs
- Fast quoting and binding through local agency system
- Low minimum premiums for small retail operations
Limitations
- Available in only 26 states – primarily Midwest and Southeast
- Firearms dealers, vape shops, and adult retail are excluded
- National retail chains and big-box stores need commercial package
How Auto-Owners Insurance compares for retail stores
QuoteSweep tracks 25 carriers for retail stores: 12 rated preferred, 13 standard, 0 limited and 0 that decline the class. Auto-Owners Insurance is rated preferred. These are QuoteSweep ratings, and not every one rests on a carrier's own guidelines.
Closest alternatives
- AmTrust Financial Services · Preferred · $1,500-$10,000
- biBERK · Preferred · $1,500-$8,000
- Cincinnati Financial · Preferred · $1,200-$8,000
Read the full Auto-Owners Insurance agent's guide for products, ratings and appointment notes across all classes.
Compare Other Carriers for Retail Stores
$1,500-$10,000
$1,500-$8,000
$1,200-$8,000
$500-$4,000
$1,000-$7,000
$1,200-$8,500
$1,200-$9,000
$800-$5,000
$1,500-$8,000
$1,500-$12,000
$800-$5,000
$2,000-$12,000
$1,500-$8,000
$500-$3,500
$2,000-$12,000
$400-$5,000
$2,000-$15,000
$2,000-$12,000
$3,000-$25,000
$2,500-$12,000
$2,000-$12,000
$3,000-$15,000
$500-$4,000
$1,500-$10,000