Auto repair shop insurance: garage liability, garagekeepers and what it costs

An auto repair shop needs garage liability (or general liability), garagekeepers for customers' cars in its care, property cover through a BOP or package policy, workers' comp once it hires and commercial auto for shop vehicles. Among Insureon's auto repair and mechanic customers, the median is $54 a month for general liability and $149 a month for a BOP.

Updated October 10, 2026 · By the QuoteSweep editorial team · How we research

Compare business insurance quotes

What insurance does an auto repair shop need?

A shop needs liability for injuries and damage it causes, garagekeepers for the customer cars on its lifts and lot, property cover for the building and equipment, workers' comp for its techs and commercial auto for any shop vehicle.

CoverageWhat it pays forWhere it shows up in a shop
Garage liability or general liabilityInjuries to customers and the public, damage to their property, and repairs that later cause an accidentA customer slips on oil in the bay; a brake job fails two weeks later
GaragekeepersDamage to or theft of customers' vehicles while you have themA tech drops a car off a lift; a car is vandalized on your lot overnight
Business owner's policy or package policyYour building, lifts, diagnostic equipment and lost income after a covered loss, bundled with liabilityA fire in the paint area closes the shop for a month
Workers' compensationMedical bills and lost wages for injured employeesBurns, back strains, crush injuries under a car
Commercial autoAccidents in vehicles the shop ownsA parts runner, shuttle van or tow truck
Tools and equipment (inland marine)Tools and equipment that leave the buildingRoad-service kits, mobile scan tools
UmbrellaExtra limits above liability, auto and employer's liabilityA serious injury claim that exceeds your primary limit

Insureon's auto repair page adds cyber cover for shops that store card details. If you also send techs to customers' homes or fleets, the mobile mechanic insurance page covers the van, the driveway and the tools that travel.

When you're ready, compare business insurance quotes and describe the shop in full: bays, services, overnight storage and road tests.

Is garage liability the same as general liability?

No. Garage liability is a version of general liability written for auto businesses, and a shop should ask for it by name.

Insureon describes garage liability as a type of general liability for garage-based businesses and says a standard general liability policy doesn't apply to hazardous workplaces like a garage. Progressive's garage insurance page gives the claim most shops worry about: brakes you replaced fail two weeks later, the customer sues, and the liability policy pays your defense and settlement. That is completed-operations cover, and it's worth confirming it's on your policy.

Neither policy pays to repair the customer's car itself. That job belongs to garagekeepers, covered next. For a longer explainer, read garage liability insurance.

What does garagekeepers insurance cover?

Garagekeepers pays for damage to customers' vehicles while they're in your care for service, repair, parking or storage. Insureon's FAQ warns that if you work on, store, tow or test-drive customer vehicles, general liability alone may not be enough.

The standard industry wording is ISO's Garagekeepers Coverage endorsement, CA 99 37. Here is what that form does:

FeatureWhat CA 99 37 says
What it's attached toA business auto, motor carrier or truckers policy, not a general liability policy
What it paysLoss to a customer's car left in your care while you attend, service, repair, park or store it
Perils you chooseComprehensive (any cause except collision or overturn) or specified causes (fire, lightning, explosion, theft, vandalism), plus collision
LimitPer loss, at each location listed in the schedule
Not coveredFaulty work you performed, defective parts or materials, theft by you or your employees, liability you take on by contract

Insurers don't all build it the same way. ERGO NEXT says it includes garagekeepers in its Pro and Pro Plus general liability policies, while the ISO form rides on an auto policy. Ask which policy carries it and which locations are listed.

Insureon's garagekeepers page adds that personal items inside the car, such as phones and the contents of the trunk or glove box, aren't covered unless you add that option.

It depends on whether you want the policy to pay only when you're at fault. The ISO form offers three bases:

BasisWhen it pays, per CA 99 37Insureon's description
Legal liability (the default)Only for sums you're legally obligated to payThe most common type
Direct excessKeeps legal liability cover, and also pays regardless of fault, after the customer's own insuranceA cheaper alternative to direct primary
Direct primaryPays regardless of fault, before the customer's insuranceCovers vandalism, weather and theft, whoever is at fault

The difference shows up on fault-free losses. A hailstorm on your lot, with no negligence on your part, isn't a legal liability loss, so a legal-liability-only policy may not pay it. Progressive's page uses overnight vandalism on the lot as a garagekeepers legal liability example, so wording varies. Ask your insurer, in writing: "If a customer's car is damaged on my lot and I wasn't negligent, does this policy pay?"

Insureon reports that auto service professionals pay an average of $38 a month for garagekeepers. Set the limit to the value of the cars you typically hold at one time, per location.

Can my shop get a BOP, or do I need a package policy?

Many shops can. Insureon says small, low-risk auto service businesses are often eligible for a BOP, and that the BOP is the policy its agents most often recommend for shops that rent or own their space. The Hartford's garage page says most garage businesses start with a BOP.

Insureon suggests medium-sized or higher-risk shops consider a commercial package policy (CPP), which it describes as more flexible than a BOP. Insureon's auto repair and mechanic customers pay a median of $149 a month for a BOP and $101 a month for a CPP.

The property side should list everything that's expensive to replace: lifts, alignment racks, diagnostic equipment, compressors and parts inventory. Progressive notes you can add machinery breakdown and tools and equipment options to its BOP. Two questions worth asking:

Who pays if a tech crashes a customer's car on a road test?

Insurers describe this claim differently, so settle it before it happens.

InsurerWhat its page says about a road-test crash
InsureonGaragekeepers pays for the customer's car; garage liability pays for the other car and its driver
ProgressiveCommercial auto pays to repair the customer's car
ERGO NEXTHired and non-owned auto is "required for longer test drives off your lot," added to general liability for when you or employees drive a customer's car

Sources: Insureon garagekeepers, Progressive auto mechanic insurance, ERGO NEXT auto service insurance, all read October 10, 2026.

Don't count on the technician's own car insurance. The ISO Personal Auto Policy (PP 00 01, 1998 edition, as filed with the Maine Bureau of Insurance) excludes liability while someone works in the business of repairing or servicing vehicles, and says this "includes road testing and delivery." It also excludes physical damage to a non-owned car used in that business.

Ask your agent: "If an employee road-tests a customer's car and causes a crash, which of my policies pays for the other driver, and which pays for the customer's car?" If you also move cars for customers or employees run errands in their own cars, ask about hired and non-owned auto cover.

Does insurance cover a bad repair?

Usually not under garagekeepers. CA 99 37 excludes faulty work and defective parts, and Insureon says a complaint about a poor repair job isn't a garagekeepers claim.

Two other policies can respond:

Ask whether the cost of redoing the work is covered, or only the damage the repair caused.

What workers' comp class is an auto repair shop?

In states that use NCCI classes, a general repair shop is usually class 8380, "Automobile Service or Repair Center & Drivers." Body shops have their own class, 8393, "Automobile Body Repair," and office-only staff go under 8810, "Clerical Office Employees NOC." Those descriptions come from the North Carolina rates table, which uses NCCI's wording. California, New York, Pennsylvania and several other states use their own systems, so check the class code lookup and ask your insurer.

Insureon says workers' comp is required in almost every state for repair shops with employees. The exceptions are narrow: Texas lets private employers opt out, South Dakota has no mandate, and Wyoming requires it only for listed hazardous work. In North Dakota, Ohio, Washington and Wyoming you buy it from the state fund and add stop-gap employer's liability. See workers' comp requirements by state.

Insureon's auto repair and mechanic customers pay a median of $150 a month for workers' comp. Payroll and class drive the price, so describe body and paint work accurately on the application; the year-end payroll audit checks what you reported.

Do I need a license to run a repair shop?

It depends on the state. In California, any business that diagnoses, services or repairs vehicles for pay must register as an automotive repair dealer with the Bureau of Automotive Repair. That includes mobile, referral and sublet repair. The application fee is $200, and so is the annual renewal. Individual mechanics working for a shop don't need a BAR license; the registration belongs to the business.

QuoteSweep hasn't checked other states' shop rules for this page. Ask your state's consumer protection or motor vehicle agency, and your city about zoning and waste-oil permits, before you open.

How much does auto repair shop insurance cost?

Among Insureon's auto repair and mechanic customers, general liability has a median of $54 a month and a BOP $149 a month. Workers' comp and commercial auto add to that once you have staff and vehicles.

PolicyMedian per monthMedian per yearTypical policy
General liability$54$652$1M per occurrence / $2M aggregate, $500 deductible
Business owner's policy (BOP)$149$1,787$1M / $2M, $1,000 deductible
Commercial package policy (CPP)$101$1,208–
Workers' compensation$150$1,796–
Commercial auto$103$1,227–
Garagekeepers$38 (average)––

Sources: Insureon's figures for its own customers, from its auto repair and mechanic cost page (updated April 7, 2025) and garagekeepers page, read October 10, 2026. Insureon calls these averages; its method note says they are medians of policies for auto repair and mechanic businesses that apply through it.

What moves your price, per Insureon: the type of shop (general repair, body, tire and brake), the value of equipment such as lifts and paint booths, revenue, location, how many customer cars you store, test-drive or service, the number of bays and technicians, limits, deductibles and claims history. ERGO NEXT says it offers up to 19% off for shops with ASE, I-CAR Gold Class or AAA-approved certification that bundle liability and property.

For a fuller breakdown, see auto repair shop insurance cost.

Who writes auto repair shop insurance?

QuoteSweep doesn't publish carrier-by-carrier appetite for auto repair, because we haven't verified it against each insurer's own underwriting pages. Progressive, The Hartford and ERGO NEXT all publish pages for repair shops, and Insureon quotes the class as a broker. That tells you who markets to shops, not who will accept yours.

Ask each insurer the same questions so the quotes compare: Is garagekeepers on a legal liability, excess or primary basis, and at which locations? Which policy pays on a road test? Is faulty work covered? Clients and landlords will also want proof, so ask how fast you can get a certificate of insurance.

Frequently asked questions

What insurance does an auto repair shop need?

Garage liability or general liability, garagekeepers for customers' cars in your care, property cover through a BOP or commercial package policy, workers' comp once you have employees and commercial auto for vehicles the shop owns. Larger shops often add an umbrella.

What is the difference between garage liability and garagekeepers?

Garage liability pays for injuries and damage your operations cause to other people and their property. Garagekeepers pays for damage to customers' vehicles while they're in your care for service, repair, parking or storage. Most shops carry both.

Does garagekeepers cover damage if the shop wasn't at fault?

Only if you buy it that way. Under ISO's standard endorsement, garagekeepers applies on a legal liability basis unless you choose the direct excess or direct primary option, which pay regardless of fault.

Can an auto repair shop get a business owner's policy?

Often, yes. Insureon says small, low-risk auto service businesses are often eligible, and The Hartford says most garage businesses start with a BOP. Higher-risk or larger shops may need a commercial package policy instead.

How much does auto repair shop insurance cost?

Among Insureon's auto repair and mechanic customers, the median is $54 a month for general liability, $149 for a BOP, $150 for workers' comp and $103 for commercial auto. Insureon reports garagekeepers at an average of $38 a month.

Does my technician's personal auto policy cover a road test?

Not under the standard ISO personal auto form. It excludes liability while someone is in the business of repairing or servicing vehicles and says that includes road testing. Settle which shop policy pays before your techs drive customer cars.

Ready to compare? Tell insurers how many bays you run, what work you do, how many customer cars you keep overnight and whether you road-test or tow, then compare business insurance quotes.

Compare business insurance quotes

Related business types

Ready to compare business insurance quotes?

Tell us about your business once and see what insurers offer.

Compare quotes