There is no single best small business insurance company. The right one depends on what you need most. Start with The Hartford if you want one insurer that sells every core policy itself, biBERK for the highest financial strength rating (A++), NEXT for the quickest online purchase, Hiscox if you sell advice or professional services, and Thimble if you only need cover for a job or a season. If you'd rather answer one set of questions and see what several insurers offer, you can compare business insurance quotes through a licensed broker.
Our picks at a glance
Every "best for" below comes from something the provider publishes: a product it sells, a rating on its own site, or how it sells policies. We read each provider's pages on 10 October 2026.
| Provider | Best for | Why |
|---|---|---|
| The Hartford | One insurer for every core policy | Sells a BOP, general liability, professional liability, workers' comp and commercial auto itself, plus cyber as an add-on or standalone policy |
| biBERK | Highest financial strength rating | biBERK says its main Berkshire Hathaway insurers are rated A++ by AM Best, the top grade |
| NEXT (ERGO NEXT) | Buying a basic package online fast | NEXT says you can get a quote and buy in less than 10 minutes |
| Hiscox | Professional services firms | Professional liability (E&O) is a core Hiscox product, with pages for consultants, IT, marketing and design professions |
| Thimble | Short jobs and seasonal work | Sells cover by the job, month or year and lets you pause or cancel |
How we chose these providers
We started from the insurers small-business owners can buy from online, then kept the ones that pass every test below. We don't accept payment for placement on this list.
- You can buy online. The provider's own site lets a business owner get a quote and buy without going through a local agent.
- The insurer is rated A- or better by AM Best. We read the rating on the insurer's own site and name the company that holds it. A- is also the floor Amazon sets for its sellers' insurers, a useful benchmark for "strong enough". AM Best's own site shows ratings only to registered users, so we didn't use it.
- Lines come from the product menu. We list a policy as "sells" only if the provider's site sells it, and we say when a provider passes a line to a partner insurer.
- Each "best for" has a published reason. No review scores, survey ratings or "editor's opinion".
Brokers that shop several insurers for you (Kinro, Coverdash, Panta) aren't ranked here because they don't issue policies; the insurer they place you with does. They're covered in should I buy direct or use a broker.
How do the providers compare?
All five sell online. The difference is what each one underwrites itself and who stands behind it.
| Provider | Type | Sells itself | Passes to a partner | Buy online | AM Best rating (checked 10 Oct 2026) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Hartford | Insurer | BOP, GL, PL, workers' comp, commercial auto, cyber | None in this list | Yes | A+ for Hartford Fire Insurance Company (The Hartford) |
| biBERK | Insurer (Berkshire Hathaway) | GL, BOP, PL, workers' comp, commercial auto, umbrella; cyber as an add-on | None in this list | Yes | A++ for its major Berkshire Hathaway subsidiaries, per biBERK |
| NEXT (ERGO NEXT) | Insurer (Munich Re's ERGO Group) | GL, BOP, PL, workers' comp, property, tools and equipment, EPLI | Commercial auto (Progressive) | Yes | A+ (Superior), announced 16 Sept 2025 (NEXT) |
| Hiscox | Insurer | GL, PL, BOP, cyber, short-term liability | Workers' comp (The Hartford), commercial auto (GEICO) | Yes | A (Excellent) for Hiscox Insurance Company Inc. (Hiscox) |
| Thimble | Agency (owned by Arch Insurance Group) | Places GL, PL, BOP, property, equipment and workers' comp with partner insurers | All policies are written by partner insurers | Yes | Thimble says its insurers are rated A- or better (Thimble) |
Workers' comp: four states (North Dakota, Ohio, Washington, Wyoming) sell it only through a state fund, so no private insurer on this list sells it there. Confirm your state is eligible for every line in the quote flow.
The partner column matters at claim time. A Hiscox workers' comp claim goes to The Hartford, and a NEXT auto claim goes to Progressive, because those companies issued the policies. Our Hiscox vs NEXT vs biBERK comparison goes line by line, and if you are leaving NEXT, see ERGO NEXT alternatives by need.
Which companies are cheapest?
None of these insurers publishes a rate table, so the honest answer is "get two quotes on the same limits". What they do publish is a starting price, and the starting price is lower than most owners pay.
| Price signal | Figure | What it is |
|---|---|---|
| NEXT general liability | from $19 a month | NEXT's advertised starting price, with its own disclaimer |
| Hiscox general liability | from $30 a month | Hiscox's advertised starting price |
| biBERK BOP | from about $500 a year; "most people pay less than $2,000" | biBERK's own claim |
| Insureon customers, general liability | $45 a month (median) | What Insureon's small-business customers paid |
| Insureon customers, BOP | $83 a month (median) | What Insureon's small-business customers paid |
The Insureon figures are Insureon's figures for its own customers, mostly very small businesses. Hiscox also says you can save up to 5% by buying two or more of its policies, and biBERK says buying direct can cost "up to 20% less". Both are marketing claims you can only test with a quote. For costs by policy and industry, see how much small business insurance costs.
The picks in detail
The Hartford: best for one insurer for every core policy
The Hartford is the pick if you want your BOP, workers' comp, commercial auto and cyber with one company. Its business menu lists a business owner's policy, general liability, professional liability, workers' comp and commercial auto, and it offers cyber either added to a BOP or as a standalone policy. Its main property and casualty insurer, Hartford Fire Insurance Company, is rated A+ by AM Best.
- Buying: you can quote and buy online, and The Hartford says it has been ranked the No. 1 digital small business insurer by Keynova seven years running (its own claim).
- Fit: businesses with a location, staff or vehicles, where having every policy under one claims team helps.
- Watch for: The Hartford doesn't advertise a starting price, so you won't know where it lands until you quote.
biBERK: best for the highest financial strength rating
biBERK is Berkshire Hathaway's direct small-business insurer. It says all of the group's major insurance subsidiaries are rated A++ by AM Best, the highest grade, and it sells general liability, a BOP, professional liability, workers' comp, commercial auto and umbrella without a broker.
- Buying: online or by phone. biBERK says cutting out the broker lets it price "up to 20% less".
- Fit: contractors, shops and restaurants that need several lines, including workers' comp and auto, from one insurer.
- Watch for: cyber is only an add-on to a GL, professional liability or BOP policy, not a standalone policy.
- Berkshire family: biBERK is one of several Berkshire Hathaway insurers; this explainer shows how it differs from GUARD and BHSI.
NEXT: best for buying a basic package online fast
NEXT, now ERGO NEXT and owned by Munich Re's ERGO Group, says you can get a quote and buy in less than 10 minutes. Its menu covers general liability, a BOP, workers' comp, professional liability, commercial property, tools and equipment, and employment practices liability. AM Best rated it A+ (Superior) in September 2025.
- Buying: fully online, with general liability advertised from $19 a month.
- Fit: owner-operators and small teams who need GL, a BOP or workers' comp today, for example to send a client a certificate.
- Watch for: commercial auto is a Progressive policy, and NEXT's main product menu lists no cyber or umbrella policy.
Hiscox: best for professional services
Hiscox suits consultants, IT and marketing firms, architects and other businesses whose main risk is a client saying your work cost them money. Professional liability is one of its core products, it lists dedicated pages for those professions, and it sells cyber. Hiscox Insurance Company Inc. is rated A (Excellent).
- Buying: online, with general liability advertised from $30 a month.
- Fit: service firms with few or no employees and no business vehicles.
- Watch for: workers' comp comes from The Hartford and commercial auto from GEICO, so those policies and claims sit with them.
- Not the right fit? See Hiscox alternatives.
Thimble: best for short-term or seasonal cover
Thimble is an online agency owned by Arch Insurance Group. It sells general liability and other policies from partner insurers by the job, month or year, and lets you modify, pause or cancel from its app. It says it covers all 50 states plus DC and uses insurers rated A- or better.
- Buying: online, in the app or by phone.
- Fit: contractors and side businesses that need a certificate for one job or a few busy months.
- Watch for: if you work year-round, compare the monthly cost with an annual policy from the insurers above.
Which is best for my type of business?
Pick by your biggest exposure, then quote at least two providers on identical limits.
| Your business | Start with | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Consultant, IT or marketing firm | Hiscox, then NEXT | Professional liability is the main risk; both have professional-services pages |
| Shop or retail store | The Hartford, biBERK or NEXT | All three have dedicated retail pages and sell a BOP |
| Contractor or trade with employees | biBERK or The Hartford | Both sell workers' comp and commercial auto themselves |
| Business with vehicles | The Hartford or biBERK | They write commercial auto themselves; NEXT and Hiscox pass auto to partners |
| Solo operator who needs a certificate this week | NEXT or Thimble | Fast online purchase; Thimble if it's for one job |
| Declined elsewhere, or high-hazard work | A broker | A broker can reach insurers that don't sell online, including the surplus lines market |
QuoteSweep's appetite data, built from each insurer's own industry pages (checked 4 March 2026), backs the first two rows: The Hartford, biBERK and NEXT each have a retail page, and all four of The Hartford, biBERK, NEXT and Hiscox have professional-services pages. Retailers can read more in our retail store insurance guide.
Should I buy direct or use a broker?
Buy direct if your business is simple and one of the insurers above has a page for your type of work. Use a broker if you've been declined, your work is unusual or high-hazard, or you want several insurers' prices without filling in several forms.
A broker doesn't issue the policy; it shops insurers for you and the insurer it places you with issues the policy. So the rating that matters is that insurer's. Ask the broker which insurer each quote is from.
- Kinro says its licensed agents help you identify coverage and shop available options, and that viewing a quote costs nothing. Our compare quotes form sends your answers to Kinro.
- Panta focuses on construction, trucking and logistics, and manufacturing.
Before any quote, gather your revenue, payroll, headcount and claims history. Our checklist of what you need for a business insurance quote lists the rest.
What coverage does a small business need?
Most small businesses start with general liability or a BOP and add policies as they hire, drive or sign contracts.
- Business owner's policy (BOP): general liability and property in one policy, the usual starting point for a business with premises or equipment.
- General liability: injuries to other people and damage to their property. Leases and client contracts may require it.
- Workers' comp: required once you have employees in almost every state. Texas lets private employers opt out, South Dakota has no mandate, and Wyoming requires it only for listed hazardous work.
- Professional liability (E&O): if you give advice or provide a professional service.
- Commercial auto: if the business owns or uses vehicles for work.
- Cyber: if you store customer data or take card payments.
Our business insurance guide covers each policy and what your state requires. LLC owners can start with the best insurance for an LLC, and online sellers with insurance for e-commerce businesses.
Get quotes
Quote two providers on the same limits and deductible, then compare the total price and what each policy excludes. If you'd rather fill in one form, a broker can shop several insurers at once.
Or use our four-question form to compare business insurance quotes.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best insurance company for a small business?
There isn't one. The Hartford fits a business that wants every core policy from one insurer, biBERK has the highest AM Best rating (A++, per biBERK), NEXT is the quickest online buy, Hiscox suits professional services, and Thimble suits short jobs. Quote two that fit your business.
Which small business insurance companies have the best AM Best ratings?
Of the insurers here, biBERK's main Berkshire Hathaway subsidiaries are rated A++, Hartford Fire Insurance Company and NEXT are A+, and Hiscox Insurance Company Inc. is A. All are above the A- floor Amazon sets for its sellers' insurers.
How much does small business insurance cost?
Insureon's small-business customers paid a median $45 a month for general liability and $83 a month for a BOP. Advertised starting prices are lower: NEXT from $19 a month and Hiscox from $30 a month for general liability. See how much small business insurance costs for figures by industry.
Can I buy small business insurance online?
Yes. The Hartford, biBERK, NEXT, Hiscox and Thimble all let you quote and buy online. Businesses with unusual or high-hazard work may still need a broker.
Is it better to use a broker or buy direct?
Buy direct if your business is simple and an insurer has a page for your type of work. Use a broker if you've been declined or want several quotes from one form. The policy still comes from an insurer, so check that insurer's rating.
What insurance should an LLC have?
The same as any business doing the same work: forming an LLC doesn't change what you need. See the best insurance for an LLC.
The bottom line
Ignore the advertised floors. A $19 general liability policy and a $45 one can carry different limits, deductibles and exclusions, so the only fair comparison is two quotes on identical terms. Get them from the two providers above that fit your business, or compare quotes from several insurers with one form. More provider reviews are on the small-business insurtech hub.

