Best Plumber Insurance (2026): 8 Carriers Compared
Most plumbers start with general liability and workers' comp, add commercial auto for service vans, and cover tools with inland marine or a tools add-on. Plumbing businesses that buy through Insureon pay a median $147 a month for general liability (Insureon, August 2026). Travelers, The Hartford and Progressive publish plumbing pages, NEXT and biBERK sell online, and the right mix depends on your employees, vehicles and claims history.
This is an independent comparison. We don't sell insurance. It covers eight carriers: Hartford, Travelers, biBERK, NEXT, Hiscox, Progressive, Acuity and Erie. Our carrier directory lists 540+ commercial carriers if none of these fits. If you'd rather have one licensed independent agent quote several of them, jump to the form.
What do plumbing contractors need?
Most plumbing accounts are built from five lines, and you usually buy them from more than one carrier:
- General liability: the foundation. Water damage from a failed job is the main exposure, and Insureon names repiping, water heater installs and sewer and septic work as reasons plumbers' premiums rise.
- Workers' compensation: needed once you have employees; the threshold varies by state.
- Commercial auto: for vans and trucks used in the business. It is the largest line in Insureon's plumber figures.
- Inland marine: tools and equipment that travel between job sites. Insureon says items worth over $2,500 may need to be listed separately.
- BOP: general liability bundled with property, for plumbers who work from a shop or office. Insureon says only small, low-risk businesses qualify.
Plumbers working as subcontractors on commercial jobs may also need umbrella or excess liability to meet the limits a general contractor requires. Check your state or local licensing board for any insurance or surety bond a plumber's license requires; Insureon says some work needs a bond, with plumbing customers paying a median $8 a month for it.
What does plumber insurance cost in 2026?
Plumbing businesses that buy through Insureon pay these medians, per Insureon's plumber cost page as read for QuoteSweep's plumber insurance cost breakdown on 10 October 2026 (Insureon figures dated August 2026). The medians assume $1 million per occurrence, $2 million aggregate and a $500 deductible. Insureon labels them averages; its method note says medians.
| Coverage | Median monthly | Median annual |
|---|---|---|
| Commercial auto | $285 | $3,415 |
| Business owners policy (BOP) | $213 | $2,559 |
| Workers' compensation | $179 | $2,150 |
| General liability (GL) | $147 | $1,768 |
| Commercial umbrella | $93 | $1,111 |
| Professional liability (E&O) | $67 | $808 |
insureon.com returns 403 to automated fetches. The general liability figure ($147 a month) was confirmed on 7 November 2026 through a search copy of Insureon's contractor cost page; the other rows come from the 10 October read. This page previously showed lower figures ($115 GL, $166 BOP, $195 workers' comp, $225 auto) that match older TechInsurance averages and have been replaced. Your price depends on the work you do (commercial jobs, repiping, water heaters and sewer lines cost more), payroll, vehicles, state and claims history.
How do the eight carriers compare?
Each row shows what the carrier publishes or what we could confirm, and separately QuoteSweep's plumbing appetite rating. Every plumbing rating in the table is a QuoteSweep estimate (recorded March 2026), not a statement by the carrier, so use it as a starting point and confirm in the quote flow. AM Best ratings are from each carrier's QuoteSweep profile unless noted, and were not rechecked on 7 November.
| Carrier | What the carrier publishes for plumbers | Plumbing appetite (QuoteSweep estimate) | AM Best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hartford | A plumbing insurance page that names plumbing contractors, septic system, drainage and sewer hookup contractors | Preferred | A+ (Superior) |
| Travelers | A plumbing and mechanical contractors page: IndustryEdge program with general liability, workers' comp, auto liability and physical damage, and umbrella/excess; property, inland marine, surety and CyberRisk are listed as related products | Preferred | A++ (Superior) |
| biBERK | Contractor pages and plumbing business insurance guidance; sells GL, BOP, workers' comp, commercial auto and umbrella itself | Preferred | A++ (Superior), per biBERK |
| NEXT (ERGO NEXT) | A plumber page listing GL, workers' comp and a tools and equipment add-on, with up to 10% off for bundling two or more policies; commercial auto is placed with Progressive | Preferred | A+ (Superior), Sept 2025 |
| Hiscox | A contractors page; sells GL and a BOP, refers workers' comp to The Hartford and commercial auto to GEICO | Limited | A (Excellent) |
| Progressive Commercial | A plumbing insurance page centred on commercial auto for vans, trucks and trailers | Preferred | A+ (Superior) |
| Acuity | Regional mutual; no plumbing page confirmed this session | Preferred | A+ (Superior) |
| Erie | Regional mutual; no plumbing page confirmed this session | Preferred | A+ (Superior) |
Sources: Travelers' plumbing and mechanical contractors page (read 7 November 2026); NEXT's plumber page, Hartford's plumbing page and Progressive's plumbing page as shown in search results (those sites return 403 to automated fetches); the Hiscox, NEXT and biBERK line facts from Hiscox vs NEXT vs biBERK. Acuity and Erie write only in their own territories, so check that your state is in their footprint on their profile pages.
Want one agent to quote several of these for you?
You don't have to call eight carriers. We'll match you with a licensed independent agent in your state who can run quotes with several carriers on your behalf and walk you through the differences.
Free. No sales pitch. We'll send a personal intro within a business day.
Online insurer or independent agent?
Both work, and plumbers often mix them.
- Online insurers (NEXT, biBERK, Hiscox) sell direct. NEXT says you can "get a quote and buy in less than 10 minutes", and NEXT's plumber page lists general liability, workers' comp and tools and equipment. biBERK sells the widest set of lines itself (GL, BOP, workers' comp, commercial auto, umbrella). Hiscox sells GL and a BOP but refers workers' comp and auto out, so a plumber with employees and vans ends up with several insurers.
- Independent agents can quote carriers that do not sell direct, such as Travelers, Hartford, Acuity and Erie, and can place auto with Progressive. The trade-off is time: an agent-led quote involves a submission and underwriter review, so it takes longer than a direct quote. We do not have a sourced turnaround for either route.
Are online insurers like NEXT good for plumbing businesses? NEXT and biBERK both publish contractor content and quote plumbers online, and the QuoteSweep appetite estimate for plumbers is Preferred for both. That is an estimate, not NEXT's or biBERK's statement. The practical limits are on lines, not appetite: NEXT's commercial auto is a Progressive policy, so an auto claim goes to Progressive.
How to choose
Match the carrier to what you need to buy:
- Solo plumber or a small shop: quote NEXT and biBERK online, and compare against Hiscox if the work is mostly residential service. Ask each whether workers' comp and auto are sold by the insurer itself or a partner.
- Employees, vans and tools: ask an agent to quote Hartford and Travelers. Travelers' plumbing program lists general liability, workers' comp, auto and umbrella, with inland marine as a related product.
- Fleet-heavy business: get a separate commercial auto quote from Progressive, whose plumbing page is built around vans, trucks and trailers.
- Regional mutuals: if your state is in Acuity's or Erie's footprint, add a quote; both write through independent agents per their QuoteSweep profiles. The Erie appetite guide covers which classes Erie writes and declines.
- Whatever you choose: quote at least three on the same limits and deductible, and compare full price, not an advertised starting price.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does plumber insurance cost?
Plumbing businesses that buy through Insureon pay a median $147 a month for general liability ($1,768 a year), $213 for a BOP, $179 for workers' compensation and $285 for commercial auto, per Insureon's August 2026 figures. See our plumber insurance cost breakdown for the per-coverage medians, a worked quote example and the underwriting questions to expect.
What insurance do I need as a plumber?
Most plumbing businesses need general liability for property damage and bodily injury claims, workers' compensation once you have employees, commercial auto for vehicles used in the business, inland marine for tools and equipment, and a BOP if you operate out of a shop. Subcontractors on commercial jobs often need umbrella cover to meet a general contractor's limits.
What's the best commercial auto for a plumbing company with service vans?
Progressive Commercial publishes a plumbing insurance page for vans, trucks and trailers, and Travelers lists auto liability and physical damage in its plumbing and mechanical contractor program. NEXT places commercial auto with Progressive, and Hiscox refers it to GEICO. Quote auto separately from your liability program if the fleet is more than a couple of vehicles.
Do I need workers' comp as a solo plumber with no employees?
Workers' comp is generally tied to having employees, but the threshold varies by state, so check your state's rule. Some general contractors also require subcontractors to carry it regardless of headcount. Four states (North Dakota, Ohio, Washington, Wyoming) require employers to buy it from a state fund.
How do I compare insurance quotes for a plumbing business?
Get at least three quotes on the same limits and deductible, with the same lines. Compare general liability, workers' comp and auto separately, since different carriers may win on each. Check who underwrites each line, because NEXT and Hiscox pass some lines to partner insurers, and compare the full price, not an advertised starting price. An independent agent can quote several carriers from one set of details.
Can I get plumber insurance with a prior water damage claim?
Often yes, but a claims history can raise premiums and narrow the options, and Insureon lists claims history as a cost driver. Be ready to explain what happened and what you changed, and have loss runs from your current carrier ready.
Who offers fast certificates of insurance for plumbers?
Online insurers are built for this. NEXT says policyholders can download and share certificates at no extra charge (stated on its Amazon seller page; confirm the same for a plumbing policy). Ask any carrier or agent how quickly they issue a certificate and whether there is a fee.
Should I buy direct from biBERK, NEXT or Hiscox, or go through an agent?
If your needs are simple, direct quotes are quick. If you have employees, vehicles or claims history, an agent can quote carriers that do not sell direct and place each line with the best fit. See the comparison above.
Get quotes from a local independent agent
If you'd rather have one licensed agent in your state run quotes with several of these carriers and walk you through the differences, fill out the form below. Free. No obligation.
QuoteSweep is not an insurance broker and does not sell insurance. We connect small businesses with licensed independent agents in our network at no cost to you. Agents may pay QuoteSweep a referral fee. Your information is shared only with the agent we match you to.
Last verified
- 7 November 2026: Travelers' plumbing page (read directly); the plumbing pages of NEXT, Hartford and Progressive and the Insureon general liability figure (search copies); NEXT's, Hiscox's and biBERK's line facts (from the Week 1 checks of Hiscox vs NEXT vs biBERK).
- Not verified: the Insureon rows other than general liability (10 October read), AM Best ratings other than NEXT's, Acuity's and Erie's plumbing appetite and footprints, and every plumbing appetite rating, which is a QuoteSweep estimate. Removed because no public source supports them: the carrier-by-carrier "what they decline" paragraphs, quote-turnaround times, "30-50%" price spreads, revenue and employee caps by carrier, and the MoneyGeek price range.

